A Defense of Rule: Origins of Political Thought in Greece by Stuart Gray

By Stuart Gray

At its middle, politics is all approximately family of rule. hence one of many important preoccupations of political idea is what it capacity for people to rule over each other or proportion in a strategy of ruling. whereas political theorists are likely to regard rule as an important evil, this booklet goals to give an explanation for how rule don't need to be understood as anathema to political lifestyles. relatively, by means of taking a look at many of the earliest traditions of political proposal we will be able to reconsider rule in ways in which evoke stewardship instead of domination.

Stuart grey argues that hierarchical principles approximately rule coevolved with political divisions among the human and non-human in western concept. The earliest discernible Greek concept complex an instrumental courting among people and their atmosphere, a place that has persevered into our present age. whereas this turns out a defensible place, grey issues out that such instrumental understandings of the nonhuman global have got us into severe hassle, together with difficulties of deforestation, worldwide warming, emerging sea degrees, species loss, and height oil.

To reconsider the idea that of rule, A safeguard of Rule turns to early Indian political inspiration that implies that rule is a dating predicated on stewardship. The e-book compares those traditions of idea so one can recommend that we've got a normative accountability to the surroundings, and therefore to behave in a fashion that takes the pursuits of non-human nature into consideration. Basing his argument on his personal unique translations of fundamental resources in old Greek and Sanskrit, grey exhibits while and the way early techniques of rule advanced to justify divisions among the human and nonhuman. In doing so, he argues for a reconsideration of our tasks towards the nonhuman usual world.

Show description

Read Online or Download A Defense of Rule: Origins of Political Thought in Greece and India PDF

Best political history books

The Political History of Eighteenth-Century Scotland (British History in Perspective)

This learn appears afresh on the assumption that these within the Scottish parliament who voted for the union of 1707 bought their state. the realm of Scottish politics after the union is then explored from the point of view of the folk on the most sensible of the ruling elite. it's the global of the squadrone, Argyll, Ilay, Bute and Dundas, the place there has been little civic advantage.

The Primacy of Foreign Policy in British History, 1660–2000: How Strategic Concerns Shaped Modern Britain

Exterior demanding situations, strategic threats, and battle have formed the process sleek British background. This quantity examines how Britain mobilized to fulfill those demanding situations and the way advancements within the structure, nation, public sphere, and financial system have been a reaction to international coverage matters from the recovery to the increase of latest Labour.

Reading the Bible with the Founding Fathers

No ebook was once extra obtainable or customary to the yankee founders than the Bible, and no e-book used to be extra usually alluded to or quoted from within the political discourse of the age. How and for what reasons did the founding new release use the Bible? How did the Bible effect their political tradition? laying off new mild on the most widespread rhetoric of the founding period, Daniel Dreisbach analyzes the founders' varied use of scripture, starting from the literary to the theological.

Additional info for A Defense of Rule: Origins of Political Thought in Greece and India

Example text

Such efforts entail addressing issues of translation and interpretation from the primary texts and languages—​for example, both ancient Greek and Sanskrit (Dallmayr 2004, 249). In turn, this point highlights a glaring issue that has not garnered the attention it 7 Introduction • 7 deserves: namely, the general lack in understanding of influential premodern traditions in various regions of the world, along with their potential connections to contemporary issues and dilemmas. ” In this regard, a historical-​ comparative approach heeds Godrej’s argument by providing scholars with greater historical knowledge of non-​Western traditions, especially premodern traditions of political thought, as recent investigations of non-​Western political thinkers have tended to focus on modern or contemporary figures such as Gandhi (Godrej 2006; Klausen 2014; Mantena 2012; Parel 2006, 2008), Sayyid Qutb (Euben 1999, 49‒92), and Zhang Shizhao ( Jenco 2010).

Virtues supporting the good of sustainability are compatible with such neutrality because sustainability, as Melissa Lane points out, “is a necessary ingredient of and condition on the realization of the good”—​and this would include the pursuit of any particular or substantive interest or good (2012, 20). Second, the theory of rule that I offer resonates with the following aspects of green republicanism: emphasis on responsibility or duty and common goods such as ecological sustainability and resilience to vulnerability due to our dependence on nonhuman nature;8 an active citizenry and more decentralized decision-​making; civic virtues such as justice, care, courage, and sacrifice.

If one uses historical beliefs from one cultural context as criteria to judge historical beliefs from a very different cultural context, then judgments may appear arbitrary and unjustified. In response to this objection, I argue that one can justifiably shift from talking about historical beliefs and comparisons to both pragmatic and theoretical considerations of implications particular ideas may have for our conception of rule. I respond to these challenges by unpacking the basic framework of a historical-​comparative approach.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.92 of 5 – based on 39 votes